Searching for a double peel set ash tool means weighing two different needs: moving and turning pizza, or managing ash and hot grill parts. My Best Overall pick is the CrustMaster Pizza Peel Set, which combines two peels with oven-cleaning tools. For kamado owners who want a focused cleanup kit, the Grill Grate Lifter, Gripper, and Ash Tool Set is the more targeted choice. The tradeoff is straightforward: CrustMaster covers more stages of pizza cooking but takes up more room, while the stainless steel kamado set stores compactly but does not include any pizza peels.
Get garden gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
I ranked these options by how directly their included tools serve the title’s combined peel-and-ash purpose, how useful each set is for its intended cooker, and what a buyer gives up in storage, compatibility, or scope. They are not interchangeable: the right pick depends on whether you primarily handle pizza and oven ash or charcoal grill ash and grate lifting.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- CrustMaster is the only set here with both a rectangular loading peel and a separate round turning peel.
- CrustMaster also includes a brass brush and ash rake, making it the closest fit for buyers who want pizza handling and oven maintenance in one set.
- The Grill Grate Lifter set prioritizes kamado ash removal and grate handling; it does not include a pizza peel.
- Choose by cooker first: the kamado set is described for large kamado-style grills, while CrustMaster is intended for ovens and grills.
- Storage and upkeep are the main tradeoffs: CrustMaster is bulky and calls for hand washing, while the stainless steel grill tools may feel heavy.
| CrustMaster Pizza Peel Set – 12×14″ Rectangular Peel, 9″ Round Turning Peel, Brass Brush, Ash Rake |  | Best Overall — the broadest peel-and-ash combination | Main peel: 12 x 14-inch rectangular aluminum peel | Turning peel: 9-inch round peel with non-stick surface | Cleaning tools: 40-inch brass brush and ash rake | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grill Grate Lifter, Gripper, and Ash Tool Set for Big Green Egg and Kamado Grills |  | Best for Kamado Cleanup — a focused ash and grate-handling kit | Included components: Ash rake, ash pan, and grill grate lifter | Material: Stainless steel | Handle material: Stainless steel | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| double peel set ash tool | Main peel | Turning peel | Cleaning tools | Materials |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CrustMaster Pizza Peel Set | 12 x 14-inch rectangular aluminum peel | 9-inch round peel with non-stick surface | 40-inch brass brush and ash rake | Aluminum, brass, and stainless steel |
| Grill Grate Lifter | — | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
CrustMaster Pizza Peel Set – 12×14″ Rectangular Peel, 9″ Round Turning Peel, Brass Brush, Ash Rake
For a buyer who means both pizza peels and an ash tool literally, CrustMaster is the clearer match. Its 12-by-14-inch rectangular aluminum peel is the main loading tool, while the 9-inch round turning peel has a separate job: maneuvering a pizza once it is in the oven. That division gives this set more practical range than relying on one peel for every movement. The included brass brush and ash rake add oven-maintenance tools, making this the only option in the lineup that brings pizza handling and cleanup together.
Compared with the Grill Grate Lifter set, CrustMaster is aimed at pizza preparation across ovens and grills, rather than ash removal and lifting a kamado grate. That makes it the stronger choice for regular pizza cooks, but a weaker one for someone whose main task is cleaning a large charcoal grill. The other set includes an ash pan and grate lifter; CrustMaster does not list either, so its ash tools should not be mistaken for a complete kamado maintenance kit.
The materials support different tasks: aluminum for the main peel, a non-stick surface on the round peel, and brass for the brush. The listed ergonomic handles are intended to make maneuvering easier, but the overall package weighs 2.71 kg and includes a 40-inch brush. That breadth has a storage cost. Its extra-large listing and multiple pieces may be awkward in a compact kitchen, and the supplied care information calls for hand washing. I would choose it for its dual-peel utility, not if I wanted the smallest or simplest cleaning kit.
Pros:- Includes both a rectangular loading peel and a separate round turning peel.
- Adds a brass brush and ash rake for oven maintenance.
- Designed for use with ovens and grills.
- Listed ergonomic handles support maneuvering the tools.
Cons:- The multiple pieces and 40-inch brush may be bulky to store.
- Hand washing is required according to the supplied care details.
- Does not include the dedicated ash pan and grate lifter found in the kamado set.
Best for: Home pizza cooks who want a loading peel, a separate turning peel, and basic oven-cleaning tools in one set.
Not ideal for: Kamado owners whose priority is lifting a grill grate and collecting ash in a dedicated pan, or cooks with very limited tool storage.
- Main peel:12 x 14-inch rectangular aluminum peel
- Turning peel:9-inch round peel with non-stick surface
- Cleaning tools:40-inch brass brush and ash rake
- Materials:Aluminum, brass, and stainless steel
- Listed size:Extra Large
- Item weight:2.71 kg
- Listed shape:Rectangular
- Stated use:Pizza; designed for ovens and grills
Our verdict“I rank CrustMaster first because it is the only set here to pair two pizza peels with ash-cleaning tools, though its size and lack of a dedicated ash pan matter.”
Grill Grate Lifter, Gripper, and Ash Tool Set for Big Green Egg and Kamado Grills
This set makes more sense when ash removal and grate lifting matter more than pizza handling. Its stainless steel ash rake, ash pan, and grill grate lifter address three practical jobs around a large kamado-style cooker. The grate lifter gives it a task-specific advantage over CrustMaster, which offers two peels and a brush but does not list a grate-lifting tool or ash pan.
That specialization is also its main limitation under a double peel set ash tool search. Despite “gripper” in its title, this product does not include a pizza peel, so it cannot load or turn a pizza in the way CrustMaster can. I would treat it as a companion kit for charcoal grill care, not as a substitute for a pizza peel set. The description names Big Green Egg and Kamado grills and says it suits various charcoal grills, but also cautions that it is limited to large grill models. Buyers should match the tool set to their grill size before choosing it.
The all-stainless-steel construction is a straightforward fit for a set used around grills, and hanging hooks help keep the tools together between cooking sessions. Its listed dimensions are compact, though those measurements do not mean the kit has the broad pizza-handling functions of CrustMaster. The stated drawback is weight: stainless steel tools may feel heavy for some users. There are also no detailed instructions, so a buyer unfamiliar with grate lifting or ash-pan handling should not expect much setup guidance.
Pros:- Includes an ash rake, ash pan, and grill grate lifter.
- Uses stainless steel for the tools and handles.
- Hanging hooks support organized storage.
- Designed for large kamado-style grills and other compatible charcoal grills.
Cons:- Does not include a pizza peel for loading or turning.
- The stated fit excludes small grills.
- The tools may feel heavy, and detailed instructions are not included.
Best for: Owners of large Big Green Egg, Kamado Joe, or similar kamado-style grills who want dedicated tools for ash removal and grate handling.
Not ideal for: Pizza cooks looking for a loading peel and turning peel, or owners of small grills that fall outside the stated fit.
- Included components:Ash rake, ash pan, and grill grate lifter
- Material:Stainless steel
- Handle material:Stainless steel
- Listed dimensions:5 x 5 x 3 inches
- Intended grill type:Large kamado-style and compatible charcoal grills
- Named compatibility:Big Green Egg and Kamado grills
- Storage feature:Hanging hooks
- Pizza peel included:No
Our verdict“I recommend this set to large-kamado owners who need ash and grate tools, but not to anyone expecting a two-peel pizza kit.”
How We Picked
I compared the two sets against the specific promise of a double peel set ash tool, rather than treating every grill accessory as a substitute for a pizza peel. The main question was how much of that combination each product actually delivers. CrustMaster supplies two distinct pizza peels plus an ash rake and brass brush; the kamado set supplies an ash rake, ash pan, and grate lifter, but no peel for loading or turning pizza.
I also looked at intended cooking setup, included tool roles, material information, and day-to-day tradeoffs mentioned in the supplied product details. A useful set needs to match the buyer’s cooker: a large kamado owner may value ash and grate tools more than pizza accessories, while someone baking pizza may need a broad loading peel and a smaller turning peel. I gave weight to whether the included pieces solve distinct tasks instead of merely increasing the tool count.
Finally, I factored in storage and handling. CrustMaster’s 40-inch brush and multiple tools call for more storage space, and the listed care guidance says hand washing is required. The kamado set is described as easy to store with hanging hooks, but its stainless steel tools may be heavy, and its stated fit is limited to large grills. I ranked CrustMaster first because it comes closest to the combined peel-and-ash brief; I ranked the kamado kit second as a better specialist set for grill cleanup, not as a direct pizza-peel alternative.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Double Peel Set Ash Tool
I would choose a set by the cooking task first, then check whether its tools match the cooker and available storage. These two products overlap on ash-related use, but they solve different problems.Decide what “double peel” means for your setup
If you want two tools for moving pizza, CrustMaster is the only match in this comparison: it has a rectangular loading peel and a round turning peel. Those different shapes serve different stages of cooking, so the benefit is not simply having two of the same tool. The kamado set’s grate lifter is a grill-handling accessory, not a pizza peel. I would not count it as the second peel if your aim is to load and rotate pizzas.
Match ash tools to the oven or grill
CrustMaster includes an ash rake and brass brush alongside its peels, which suits a buyer seeking pizza tools and basic oven-cleaning accessories together. The kamado set takes a more dedicated grill approach with an ash rake, ash pan, and grate lifter. Choose that one when collecting ash and handling a grill grate are central jobs. If you need both pizza peels and a dedicated ash pan, neither listed set includes every tool in that exact combination.
Check grill size and compatibility
The kamado set is described for large kamado-style grills and compatible charcoal grills, with small grills specifically ruled out. That stated fit should guide the decision before you buy. CrustMaster is presented for ovens and grills, but the supplied details do not name particular grill models. If using a grill rather than an oven, compare the tool dimensions and your cooking surface to the product details instead of assuming universal fit.
Plan for storage and cleaning
CrustMaster brings more pieces and a 40-inch brush, so its broader range takes more storage space. It also requires hand washing according to the provided details. The kamado kit is described as easy to store with hanging hooks, although its stainless steel tools may feel heavy. Think about where the set will live and how often you will clean it; a tool kit that is inconvenient to store or maintain may not suit a compact cooking area.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which set actually includes two pizza peels?
CrustMaster includes two pizza peels: a 12-by-14-inch rectangular peel and a 9-inch round turning peel. The kamado set includes a grill grate lifter, but that is not a pizza peel and is not designed for loading or turning pizza.
Which option is better for ash removal?
It depends on the cooker and the cleanup task. CrustMaster pairs an ash rake with a brass brush for oven maintenance, while the kamado kit adds a dedicated ash pan and grate lifter. For a large kamado grill, the latter is the more focused ash-and-grate set; for pizza cooking across ovens and grills, CrustMaster combines cleanup tools with its peels.
Can I use the kamado tool set with a small grill?
The supplied product details say the set is not suitable for small grills and describe it for large kamado-style grills and compatible charcoal grills. I would check the stated grill fit before choosing it rather than assuming that its tools will suit every cooker.
Which set is easier to store?
The kamado kit is described as easy to store with hanging hooks. CrustMaster has more separate pieces, including a 40-inch brush, and is listed as extra large, so it is likely to call for more storage room. The better fit depends on whether you have a place to hang grill tools or space for a longer pizza-tool set.
Do either of these sets include both pizza peels and a dedicated ash pan?
No. CrustMaster has two pizza peels and an ash rake, but its listed components do not include a dedicated ash pan. The kamado kit includes an ash pan, rake, and grate lifter, but no pizza peel. If you need both sets of functions together, check the included components carefully before buying or plan on sourcing the missing tool separately.
Conclusion
I would choose CrustMaster if I wanted a real two-peel arrangement for pizza, with an ash rake and brush included for basic oven maintenance. It is the better all-round fit for pizza cooks who have room to store a larger kit and do not need a dedicated ash pan or grate lifter. For a buyer whose priority is cleaning a large kamado grill and lifting its grate, I would pick the Grill Grate Lifter set instead; its focused tools suit that job better, but it is not a pizza-peel set. Before deciding, match the kit to your cooker and the exact tasks you expect it to handle.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
