TL;DR
Outdoor design director Brad Holley says many Baby Boomers were raised with a conventional ideal of orderly lawns and clipped shrubs, making newer styles feel unfamiliar. His explanation is an expert’s interpretation, not survey evidence establishing how all Boomers think; generational preferences and individual choices vary.
Outdoor design director Brad Holley says some Baby Boomers may resist newer landscaping styles because they were raised with a suburban ideal of short, neatly mowed lawns, trimmed shrubs and orderly flower beds. In an interview with Hunker, Holley argued that this established idea of a respectable yard can make native gardens, rewilding and other less conventional designs seem strange or untidy; his explanation is an expert’s interpretation, not a measured finding about every Boomer homeowner.
Get garden gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Holley, design director at Outdoor Dynamics, links the preference for manicured yards to a long-standing American landscape tradition associated with Andrew Jackson Downing, a 19th-century horticulturist whose writing helped shape ideas about gardens and suburban landscapes. Holley said Boomers were the last generation to follow what he called Downing’s “National Landscape Aesthetic” almost universally, while acknowledging exceptions. He also suggested that decades of seeing one style treated as normal can make alternatives feel unfamiliar.
In Holley’s account, the conventional yard is defined by visible signs of care: grass kept short, shrubs concealing a home’s foundation and a prominent tree on the front lawn. He described the look as tied to status and social expectations, including the postwar suburban ideal that a well-kept home and yard signaled prosperity and belonging. Those historical explanations are his interpretation; the interview does not provide survey data showing how widespread the preferences are today.
The trends he says can prompt resistance include synthetic turf, ground covers used instead of mulch, minimalist planting, xeriscaping and rewilding. These approaches are not interchangeable: synthetic materials are often promoted for convenience, while native planting and rewilding can reduce reliance on conventional lawn care and allow more natural growth. Holley said younger homeowners may be drawn to lower-maintenance choices or environmental concerns, but individual reasons differ.
Why Modern Outdoor Trends Can Feel Unfamiliar
Designer Brad Holley says traditional ideas of a cared-for suburban yard may shape some Boomers’ reactions to newer landscaping. His view is an interpretation, not survey evidence about an entire generation.
The familiar yard
Holley describes a conventional ideal built around visible signs of care.
Orderly lawn
Short grass, clipped shrubs and tidy flower beds can signal care and belonging.
Different definitions
Native planting, xeriscaping and rewilding challenge familiar expectations in distinct ways.
Other priorities
Synthetic turf and lower-maintenance choices offer different approaches to yard care.
One goal, different looks
Homeowners across age groups may want curb appeal and manageable upkeep.
- Can look cared for and familiar
- May fit neighborhood expectations
- Can reflect environmental concerns
- May reduce conventional lawn care
A longer landscape tradition
Holley connects suburban lawn ideals to older landscape writing and postwar suburban expectations.
Holley points to 19th-century horticulturist Andrew Jackson Downing.
Orderly front yards became associated with domestic comfort and social standing.
Native gardens, minimal planting and rewilding offer different appearances and aims.
What the account can establish
The interview describes one designer’s interpretation of a visible disagreement.
| Supported by the account | Not established |
|---|---|
| Holley’s explanation of traditional yard expectations | How many Boomers oppose each trend |
| Different landscaping styles have different aims | Whether age determines preference |
| Homeowners weigh upkeep and neighborhood expectations | Comparative costs or environmental effects |
The disagreement affects more than appearance. Homeowners deciding what to plant or remove may be balancing upkeep, water use, environmental concerns and neighborhood expectations. A manicured lawn can be a familiar signal of care to one homeowner, while another sees it as resource-intensive or too demanding to maintain. That difference can complicate shared decisions about a property, especially when family members or neighbors have contrasting ideas of what looks welcoming.
Holley also cautioned against treating the generations as having entirely opposing goals. He said homeowners across age groups want curb appeal, a clean impression and manageable maintenance. The disagreement, in his framing, is often over which landscaping choices best achieve those aims. For readers considering a change, the account offers a way to understand why a design that feels sustainable or relaxed to one person may read as neglected to another, without establishing that age alone determines preference.
Products Worth Considering

Solo Stove Pi Prime Portable Propane Pizza Oven

Greenworks 48V Cordless 3-in-1 Leaf Blower, Vacuum and Mulcher with Two 6.0Ah Batteries

EGO Power+ 21 Cordless Electric Lawn Mower Kit, Self-Propelled (LM2135SP)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Suburban Lawn Became Standard
The source of this particular account is an interview published by Hunker; no date for the interview is given in the supplied material. Holley places today’s debate within a longer history: landscape ideals associated with 19th-century writing were later reflected in the planned communities and expanding suburbs of the post-World War II era. In that setting, a closely maintained front yard became part of a broader picture of domestic comfort and social standing.
Current alternatives vary in purpose and appearance. Native landscaping uses plants suited to a local region and can still be arranged in a deliberate, balanced design. Rewilding, as Holley describes it, reduces human control further and allows more natural growth. Synthetic turf offers a different proposition, often emphasizing reduced routine lawn care rather than ecological planting. Grouping all of these options together as simply “messy” or “modern” would miss their differences.
How Broad Are These Preferences?
The interview does not include polling, demographic research or sales data showing how many Boomers reject particular landscaping styles. Holley’s statements describe his professional observations and interpretation, and should not be read as applying to every homeowner in a generation. It is also unclear how much any preference reflects age, regional climate, local rules, household budgets, maintenance needs or personal taste.
The account does not compare the environmental effects, costs or long-term maintenance requirements of the different options. It also does not establish whether younger homeowners consistently favor native planting or synthetic materials. Those details would be needed to quantify the trend or evaluate claims about the choices’ practical effects.
Choices Depend on Local Conditions
No policy change, industry data release or specific next milestone is identified in the interview. For homeowners weighing a landscaping change, the immediate next step is practical: compare the intended look with the property’s conditions and the time, water and upkeep available. Native plants, artificial turf and rewilding involve different design and maintenance choices, so the label alone does not determine whether a yard will suit a household.
Holley’s comments frame the debate as a difference in what people recognize as a cared-for yard, rather than proof that one generation has abandoned curb appeal. Whether that interpretation describes a broad shift remains unknown without representative data. Until then, the confirmed development is the designer’s explanation of a visible design disagreement, not a measured account of all homeowners’ views.
Key Questions
Why does Brad Holley say some Boomers resist newer landscaping trends?
Holley says many grew up with a conventional ideal of short lawns, trimmed shrubs and orderly planting. He argues that designs that challenge what people have long considered normal can feel unfamiliar. This is his interpretation, not a finding about every Boomer homeowner.
Which outdoor trends does Holley say can be controversial?
He names synthetic turf, alternative ground covers, minimalism, xeriscaping and rewilding. These approaches have different aims and appearances, and the interview does not show how many homeowners oppose each one.
Are native gardens necessarily messy?
No. The account says native landscaping can be orderly and visually balanced, even though it may depart from conventional lawn-care practices. Rewilding generally allows more natural growth, but the terms describe distinct approaches.
Do younger homeowners all prefer natural landscaping?
The interview describes younger generations as often drawn to lower-maintenance options or environmentally friendly practices, but it provides no survey data establishing how common those preferences are. Individual choices vary.
Source: hunker.com
